Murder On Mulberry Bend by Victoria Thompson

“You aren’t going to find out who killed Emilia Donato,” he warned her. “Nobody is going to find out. Sometimes we can’t solve these cases… you’ve got to forget about Emilia Donato, Sarah.” He waited for her to agree, but she never did.” – Victoria, Thompson, Murder On Mulberry Bend.

Murder on Mulberry Bend (2003) is the fifth book in Victoria Thompson’s popular and acclaimed Gaslight Mystery series. These novels are set in 1890s New York City. The two lead detectives throughout the series are Sarah Brandt, a nurse midwife, and Detective Frank Molloy, who works for the NYC police department.

​Sarah and Frank do not get along when they first meet in book one, Murder on Astor Place. Frank is a working-class cop, and Sarah, though she lives on the Lower East Side treating the poor, comes from a very wealthy family who live uptown. But by book five, Murder on Mulberry Bend, Sarah and Frank have respect for each other. It’s a grudging friendship with a lot more going on underneath.

​Murder on Mulberry Bend begins at night with Sarah in a carriage with Richard Dennis after a night at the opera. Richard is the kind of wealthy, successful man that Sarah’s parents are hoping she will fall for, but it becomes clear that Sarah and Richard are not suited. They lost their spouses a few years back and neither is ready for a new relationship.

​On the ride home, Richard talks about his wife Hazel, who died three years ago. Hazel, before she passed, volunteered at the Prodigal Son Mission, a shelter for destitute young women without a home or family. Richard, feeling guilty about not taking an interest in Hazel’s work while she was alive, asks Sarah to accompany him to the Prodigal Son to see how they can help.

​They visit the mission the next day and are impressed with the good work Mrs. Wells, who runs the mission, is doing. Sarah donates some of her clothes and Richard offers to host a fundraiser. They leave inspired, and Sarah plans to return to volunteer.

​Two days later, Frank Molloy is called to a murder scene in a park. A young woman is lying dead, face down, wearing Sarah’s hat and coat. Frank briefly thinks it’s Sarah and he is devastated. But the young woman is Emilia Donato, one of the young women who was staying at the mission and wearing an outfit that Sarah had donated.

​Frank and Sarah are once again on a search for the killer. Emilia had a pimp when she worked as a prostitute. She also had an abusive ex-boyfriend and a mother who disowned her. There is also the Prodigal Son Mission, where things may not be as right as they seem. The suspects abound.

​I was hooked on this Gaslight Mystery series from the first book, Murder on Astor Place. I love the setting, 1890s NYC. And in this series, Victoria Thompson shows us the other side of the Gilded Age, the Lower East Side to be specific. Thompson has done research into this time period and weaves it well into her novels.

​But ultimately what keeps me coming back is the chemistry between Frank Molloy and Sarah Brandt. It’s a slow-burn romantic relationship that still has me interested five books in, and that is very hard to pull off, but Victoria Thompson has done it because she has a real gift.

​I highly recommend these Gaslight Mysteries, and it is best to start with the first book, Murder on Astor Place.



Leave a Reply